top of page
Horizon Revenue Solutions Logo

How to Reconcile Insurance Payments, ERAs and Bank Deposits

Nov 10
3 min read

To reconcile insurance payments, match three records: the payer’s remittance, the money received in the bank, and the payment posted in your billing system. A deposit confirms that money arrived; it does not establish that each claim was posted correctly or paid at the expected rate.


This workflow is useful for practice owners and billing managers across specialties, especially when unexplained differences appear in collections reports or accounts receivable. Start with one payer and one payment batch so you can trace the difference without mixing unrelated activity.


Matte 3D medical ledger, blank calculator, bank building and paired payment slips with a checkmark.

Start with a three-record checklist

  • Remittance: identify the payer, payment amount, payment reference and claims included.

  • Bank: locate the corresponding settled deposit and its available payment details.

  • Billing system: confirm the payment batch was posted once, to the correct claims, with the appropriate adjustments.


What is the difference between an EFT and an ERA?

An electronic funds transfer (EFT) moves payment to the provider’s account. An electronic remittance advice (ERA) explains how the payer processed claims and adjusted charges. CMS explains that matching trace information in the EFT and ERA supports reassociation—connecting the payment with its explanation.


Horizon recommends using that payment reference, payer identity and amount together. Do not rely only on the bank’s abbreviated payer description or assume that two entries for the same amount belong together. If your bank view does not show the needed payment details, ask your authorized banking contact how to obtain them.


Why doesn’t the deposit match the claim payments?

A difference needs an explanation before it becomes a write-off. For Medicare, CMS’s remittance guidance describes adjustments at the service-line, claim and provider levels. Provider-level balance adjustments, commonly called PLBs, can include recovery of an earlier overpayment or interest and may not relate to a specific claim on that remittance.


Review those adjustments before comparing the total with the deposit. For example, a hypothetical remittance showing $5,000 in claim payments and a $300 recovery of a prior overpayment may explain a $4,700 deposit. The $300 difference should be traced to the recovery rather than spread across unrelated claims. This is an illustration, not a client result.


How to work through an unmatched payment

Horizon recommends the following sequence. It is an operational checklist, not a new payer requirement.


  • Deposit present, remittance missing: search the payer portal and clearinghouse using the payment reference. Confirm ERA delivery and enrollment if the issue keeps recurring.

  • Remittance present, deposit missing: verify the payment method and destination, check for a timing difference or offset, and contact the payer’s payment support team when the expected funds cannot be located.

  • Deposit and remittance match, posting differs: check for a duplicate import, an unposted batch, a reversal or a payment assigned to the wrong account.

  • Totals match, claim detail looks wrong: inspect individual service lines, adjustment reasons and patient responsibility. A balanced batch can still contain posting errors.


Avoid entering a second payment just to make a report balance. Preserve the original reference and document any reversal or correction so another team member can follow what happened.


Reconciled does not always mean paid correctly

Payment reconciliation answers whether the money received agrees with the remittance and posting records. Underpayment review asks a different question: does the payer’s allowed amount agree with the applicable contract or fee schedule? A payment can pass the first check and still need the second.


When reviewing a discrepancy, separate contractual adjustments, patient responsibility, denials, recoveries and potential underpayments. Keep unresolved amounts visible until their reason and next action are clear. Do not automatically transfer an unexplained difference to the patient or classify it as an uncollectible balance.


Keep an exception log through month-end

Record the payer, payment reference, amount, relevant dates, mismatch, assigned owner and next follow-up. Review new exceptions regularly and carry unresolved timing differences into the next reconciliation period. Closing a month should leave an explainable list of outstanding items, not an unexplained plug adjustment.


The practice and billing team should agree on who supplies bank information, who posts payments and who confirms resolution. Use authorized access and approved channels for financial and patient information.


How Horizon Can Help With Payment Reconciliation

Horizon’s full-cycle medical billing services include payment posting, adjustments, accounts receivable follow-up and detailed reporting. We can help trace unmatched payments, review posting discrepancies and identify items that need payer follow-up while working with your existing billing software.


Call (408) 444-8845 for a complimentary billing review to identify gaps between your remittances, bank deposits and posted collections. You can also contact Horizon online.

Comments


bottom of page